How to Use the Black-Scholes Model for Option Pricing

The Black-Scholes Model (also known as the Black-Scholes-Merton model) is a mathematical framework for valuing options.

It determines an option's fair value using the stock price, strike price, volatility, time to expiration, and risk-free interest rate.

At its core, the model seeks to answer the question: How much is an option worth today, given current market conditions and its potential future outcomes?

What are the assumptions of the Black-Scholes model?

The Black-Scholes model is based on several key assumptions that, although simplified, form the foundation for pricing options.

1. Efficient markets

The model assumes efficient markets, where all available information is immediately reflected in asset prices. As a result, no investor can consistently earn above-average returns based on that information.

In reality, markets can be inefficient due to factors like behavioral biases, information asymmetry, and transaction costs, which may lead to price distortions.

2. No dividends

The Black-Scholes model assumes the underlying asset does not pay dividends during the life of the option.

Variations of the model exist that incorporate dividend payments, adjusting the formula to account for the impact of dividends on the underlying asset’s value.

3. Constant risk-free rate

The model assumes that the risk-free interest rate (the rate at which money can be borrowed or lent without risk) remains constant throughout the life of the option.

In practice, interest rates fluctuate over time based on economic conditions and central bank policies, which can affect the valuation of options.

4. Constant volatility

It is assumed that the volatility of the underlying asset (a measure of how much its price fluctuates) remains constant over the option's life.

Volatility is often dynamic. It changes due to market events, economic news, or periods of uncertainty. As a result, volatility can spike or decrease, affecting the value of options.

5. Log-normal distribution of returns

The model assumes that the returns of the underlying asset follow a log-normal distribution. It means the asset’s price cannot become negative and that price changes are skewed toward positive outcomes.

In reality, asset prices may not perfectly follow a log-normal distribution. Extreme market events (like crashes or bubbles) can cause returns to deviate from this idealized pattern.

How does the Black-Scholes model work? 

According to Black-Schole model, these inputs capture the fundamental factors influencing an option's price: 

S (Stock Price): The current price of the underlying asset.

K (Strike Price): The predetermined price at which the option can be exercised. 

T (Time to Expiration): Measured in years, it represents the remaining time until the option expires. 

r (Risk-Free Rate): The annualized return of a theoretically risk-free investment, such as government bonds. 

σ (Volatility): The annualized standard deviation of the stock’s returns, representing price uncertainty. 

N(x): The cumulative probability function of the standard normal distribution, indicating the likelihood of a variable being below 𝑥.  In simple terms, it is used to calculate the likelihood of certain outcomes (like an option finishing in-the-money) based on market factors.

If N(0.5)=0.691N(0.5) = 0.691N(0.5)=0.691, it means there’s a 69.1% chance that a value from the distribution will be less than or equal to 0.5.

Each variable has a unique role in shaping the option's price, reflecting market expectations and risk.

Black-Scholes model formula

‍

Benefits of the Black-Scholes model

1. Accurate valuation of Employee Stock Options (ESOPs)

The Black-Scholes model is widely used to determine the fair value of stock options granted to employees. By assigning a clear monetary value to ESOPs, it ensures that the cost of these options is accurately reflected in financial statements. 

2. Supports capital allocation decisions

The model aids in pricing hybrid financial instruments such as convertible bonds, warrants, and equity-linked securities.

By accurately valuing these instruments, companies can optimize their financing strategies, balancing equity dilution and debt cost effectively.

3. Improves investor confidence

When companies disclose option valuations based on Black-Scholes, it enhances their credibility and reduces the perception of risk.

4. Standard method for valuing grants of public companies

For listed companies, where stock prices are publicly traded and subject to market fluctuations, Black-Scholes provides a transparent, consistent, and standardized method for valuing grants at the time of issuance.

Without the Black-Scholes model, companies might apply different valuation techniques. This could result in discrepancies in how stock-based compensation is accounted for, making financial statements less comparable and potentially misleading.

5. Compliance with financial reporting

This model is also crucial for Indian listed companies when preparing their profit and loss accounts.  

This valuation, along with the underlying assumptions—such as stock price volatility, time to expiration, and the risk-free interest rate—must be disclosed in financial reports to ensure transparency and compliance with regulatory standards like Ind AS 102.

Additionally, the model is required for generating expense reports, such as those under ASC 718 for US companies, to ensure compliance with accounting standards.

Drawbacks of the Black-Scholes model

1. Assumes market efficiency

The model assumes that stock prices reflect all available information and are free from manipulation or behavioral biases.

In reality, corporate finance decisions often occur in markets with information asymmetry, speculative trading, or irrational investor behavior, which can undermine the model’s reliability.

2. Limited for non-traditional equity instruments

Black-Scholes is designed for standard European-style options. It refers to options exercisable only at expiration.

Quick fact: European-style options are not limited to Europe; the term refers to the exercise rules of the options, not their geographic location.

Hence, the model is less effective for complex corporate instruments like performance-based stock options or convertible debt.

These instruments often have unique features, such as contingent payoffs or early conversion rights, requiring modifications or alternative models for accurate valuation.

3. Inaccurate for illiquid securities

The model works best for assets traded in liquid markets, but many corporate finance instruments, such as private equity or restricted shares, lack liquidity. Illiquidity reduces the true value of these instruments, a factor not captured by Black-Scholes.

We hope you found this blog-post helpful. For expert help with the Black-Scholes model, connect with us here.